Skip to content
Film review roundup

Clayface review roundup: critics love the gross-out body horror, split on the story

Clayface is DC Studios' R-rated body-horror film about a disfigured actor who becomes a shapeshifting monster, directed by James Watkins. Critics largely enjoyed its gruesome effects and Tom Rhys Harries' lead performance, but many found the plotting and characters thin.

The story (no spoilers)

Matt Hagen is a young actor from one of Gotham City's poorest neighbourhoods who has just earned his first Oscar nomination. One reckless night out with the girlfriend of mob boss Markos Szabo ends with his face slashed, his career collapsing and his name dragged through the press.

Desperate to get his life back, Matt volunteers for an untested cell-repair treatment developed by scientist Dr. Caitlyn Corr. At first it restores his looks, but the treatment keeps changing him, and he soon discovers that his face can take on entirely different shapes.

Where to watch or download

Links go to official services only. Streaming services let subscribers download titles in their app to watch offline, on supported plans; stores let you buy a copy to download and keep. Availability differs by country and changes over time (checked 4 November 2026). ElysiumHub does not host files or link to unofficial downloads.

The verdict

Worth it if you like your comic-book films nasty: most critics say the practical gore, a nightmarish airplane scene and a shapeshifting nightclub sequence earn the ticket price, and it plays best with a reacting crowd in a cinema. If you need a strong story, or you are squeamish, wait for the home release.

What critics say

Positive
“Unconcerned with pleasing the broadest possible crowd, the film is odd, oozy fun, both as juvenile and as adult as it needs to be.”
Guy Lodge, Variety
Positive
“Clayface is the sort of pleasurable gross-out experience that will have audiences turning their eyes and shifting in their seats while loving every minute.”
Frank Scheck, The Hollywood Reporter
Positive
“Not since the 2000s reign of the Hostel and Saw franchises have we seen a major studio movie unafraid to get this icky.”
Gabrielle Moss, Collider
Mixed
“‘Clayface’ is an effective, though hardly brilliant, gross-out horror film.”
William Bibbiani, TheWrap
Negative
“Malleable, sure, but this ambitious misfire can never conform to one shape, one final form, or one good idea.”
Kate Erbland, IndieWire

What works

  • Inventive, stomach-churning practical and digital body-horror effects.
  • Tom Rhys Harries keeps Matt sympathetic under heavy makeup.
  • Standout set pieces on an airplane and in a mobster's nightclub.
  • A standalone, R-rated tone unlike any other DC film.

What doesn't

  • Thin, broadly drawn characters and a procedural-style middle stretch.
  • The plotting grows muddled in the second half.
  • Several critics found the romance between Matt and Caitlyn forced.

What critics liked

Most reviewers agree that Clayface delivers on its promise as a body-horror film. Variety's Guy Lodge called it a pleasing throwback to 1990s genre films such as Darkman and praised its prosthetics work throughout. The Hollywood Reporter's Frank Scheck compared it with the work of David Cronenberg and Sam Raimi and described a scene set during heavy turbulence on a plane as a master class in tension. Collider's Gabrielle Moss said the film is at its best when it simply embraces being repulsive.

Where it falls short

The criticism centres on the story. IndieWire's Kate Erbland admired the big swings but felt the script collapses in its second half and the transformation effects grow muddy. Collider found the characters bare-bones and the quieter scenes closer to a TV police procedural, and TheWrap's William Bibbiani argued that the film raises a darker question about its hero and then backs away from it. The A.V. Club's Jesse Hassenger thought the horror itself was more workmanlike than the marketing suggested.

The performances

Tom Rhys Harries, a Welsh actor previously known for supporting roles, carries the film. Several critics said he keeps Matt likable even as the character turns vengeful, and IndieWire praised the pathos he conveys under the makeup and effects. Naomi Ackie's scientist won praise from Variety for adding curiosity and conscience to a stock role, while David Dencik's mobster and Eddie Marsan's business manager were cited as enjoyably slimy villains. Collider and the A.V. Club were less convinced by the chemistry between Harries and Ackie.

How it fits the DC Universe

Clayface is the third film in the rebooted DC Universe, after Superman and Supergirl, and it stands apart from both. It has no superheroes, an R rating and a horror-first approach, written by Mike Flanagan and Hossein Amini and directed by James Watkins, whose earlier films include Eden Lake and Speak No Evil. Several critics saw that independence as its biggest strength, and Deadline's Glenn Garner hoped it could serve as a roadmap for the franchise.

Should you watch?

If you enjoy body horror and can handle graphic gore, the consensus says yes, and the gasps of a full cinema are part of the fun. Clayface opened in US cinemas on 23 October 2026. It is not yet available to rent, buy or download, and Warner Bros. has not announced a digital release date.

Naomi Ackie, who plays scientist Caitlyn Corr in Clayface, holding a microphone on a panel at SXSW 2026 in Austin, Texas
Naomi Ackie at SXSW 2026 in Austin, Texas. Photo: Sara Komatsu / Wikimedia Commons · CC BY-SA 4.0 · Image source

Quick answers

Is Clayface worth watching?
Worth it if you like your comic-book films nasty: most critics say the practical gore, a nightmarish airplane scene and a shapeshifting nightclub sequence earn the ticket price, and it plays best with a reacting crowd in a cinema. If you need a strong story, or you are squeamish, wait for the home release.
What are the review scores for Clayface?
Rotten Tomatoes: 77% (Tomatometer, Certified Fresh, 213 reviews, 4 Nov 2026). Rotten Tomatoes: 94% (Popcornmeter, 2,500+ verified audience ratings, 4 Nov 2026). Metacritic: 59 (Metascore, 45 critic reviews, 4 Nov 2026).
Where can I watch Clayface?
Official options: Fandango (in cinemas; US). Availability varies by country and changes over time.
How long is Clayface?
Clayface runs 108 minutes (1 hr 48 min).
When was Clayface released?
Clayface was released on 23 October 2026 by Warner Bros. Pictures / DC Studios.
Who is in Clayface?
It is directed by James Watkins and stars Tom Rhys Harries, Naomi Ackie, David Dencik, Max Minghella, Eddie Marsan and Joshua James.

Sources

This roundup summarises the reviews and reporting below. Follow the links for the full pieces.

  1. 'Clayface' Review: DC Comics Horror Movie Is Good, Gross Fun · Variety
  2. 'Clayface' Review: Batman's Nemesis Gets a Terrific Origin Story · The Hollywood Reporter
  3. 'Clayface' Review: A Gross Miscalculation (Emphasis on the Gross) · IndieWire
  4. 'Clayface' Is Horrific To Watch for All the Right Reasons · Collider
  5. 'Clayface' Review: DC's Gross-Out Monster Movie Is Mostly Effective · TheWrap
  6. Clayface review: A Universal Monster sensibility for the DC villain · The A.V. Club
  7. Rotten Tomatoes
  8. Metacritic

ElysiumHub Screen Desk roundups summarise published reviews and reporting, and are written with AI assistance. Scores belong to the sites that publish them. Read our editorial standards. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.